icon Skip to content
Flat Rate $5.99 Shipping + Freebies With Every Order
Flat Rate $5.99 Shipping + Freebies With Every Order
Get A Printable Gift Note To Give Right Away
Get A Printable Gift Note To Give Right Away

Mustard

Aardvark Reaper

Secret Aardvark Trading Co
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99
In stock

The heat intensity will wake up your tastebuds but won’t melt your face! Well, maybe just a little. This is not a vinegar forward sauce, Aardvark ...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99

Assam

Clark & Hopkins
Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
Original price
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
Current price $11.99
In stock

A unique sauce inspired by the cuisine of Northern India, featuring tamarind, black mustard seed, a complex blend of spices, and enough Ghost peppe...

View full details
Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
Original price
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
Current price $11.99

Burns & McCoy Scotch Bonnet Pepper Sauce

Burns & McCoy
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99
Low stock

One of the most unique sauces we've tried, made with Yellow Scotch Bonnet peppers and caramelized fennel. The addition of roasted garlic and roaste...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99

Chi Banero Spicy Yellow Mustard

Fresco Sauce
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
Out of stock

 A garlicky blend of chipotle and orange habanero peppers with a hint of sweetness mixed in to bold yellow mustard. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients:...

View full details
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
Sold out

Clark & Hopkins Chesapeake Bay

Clark & Hopkins
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
In stock

A bold blend of spices, apple cider vinegar, bay leaves, Jalapeños, mustard, and ginger. Great with seafood! Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Apple Ci...

View full details
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99

Clark & Hopkins Kerala

Clark & Hopkins
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
Out of stock

A deeply fragrant and flavorful hot sauce, inspired by Southern Indian Cuisine, made with Habanero, ginger, and kaffir lime leaf. Heat Level: Mediu...

View full details
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
Sold out

Curry Fennel Fire

Heat Hot Sauce Shop
Original price $10.99 - Original price $10.99
Original price
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
Current price $10.99
Low stock

A unique blend of fresh curry spices, herbaceous and slightly sweet fennel seeds, and fiery Carolina Reaper peppers. The sauce is rounded out with ...

View full details
Original price $10.99 - Original price $10.99
Original price
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
Current price $10.99

El Chupacabra

CaJohns
Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
Original price
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
Current price $13.99
Out of stock

CaJohn's El Chupacabra Hot Sauce is a scorching concoction that combines some of the worlds hottest peppers into one sauce. Often times, a sauce s...

View full details
Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
Original price
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
Current price $13.99
Sold out

Fire Roasted Red Reaper & Garlic

Hellfire Hot Sauce
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
In stock

Don't be fooled by the label, this sauce has a moderate kick but it's mostly about the delicious flavor of garlic, fire-roasted Jalapeños, sun drie...

View full details
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99

Gold 79

Burns & McCoy
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99
In stock

Burns & McCoy Gold 79 is a mild pepper sauce, with a hint of turmeric and mustard that will leave you wanting more.  Heat Level: Mild Ingredie...

View full details
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99

Heartbreaking Dawns Classic Gold

Heartbreaking Dawns
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99
In stock

Heartbreaking Dawns Classic Gold is a great everyday hot sauce made with Red Habaneros, tomato, Scotch Bonnets, and a hint of mustard.   Heat Leve...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99

Hell Hound

Lucky Dog Hot Sauce
Original price $11.49 - Original price $11.49
Original price
$11.49
$11.49 - $11.49
Current price $11.49
In stock

Lucky Dog's hottest sauce yet, Hell Hound combines fiery Carolina Reapers with roasted peppers, mango, tamarind & roasted garlic for a well bal...

View full details
Original price $11.49 - Original price $11.49
Original price
$11.49
$11.49 - $11.49
Current price $11.49

Jalapickle Dill Hot Sauce

PexPeppers
Original price $8.99 - Original price $8.99
Original price
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
Current price $8.99
In stock

A mildly spicy sauce made with fresh jalapeños, garlic, a splash of vinegar, and classic dill pickling spices. Perfect for hot dogs, sandwiches, or...

View full details
Original price $8.99 - Original price $8.99
Original price
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
Current price $8.99

Lottie's Red Scotch Bonnet Sauce

Tejano Salsa
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
In stock

A Barbados style pepper sauce made without the traditional mustard component (see Lottie's Yellow for a mustardy version). The flavor of the red Sc...

View full details
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99

Mx. Green Sass

Shaquanda Will Feed You
Original price $9.99
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price $9.99
Current price $6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99
Out of stock

A bright verde sauce, made with onions, cilantro, citrus, banana, and a mix of Serrano and Jalapeño peppers. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Onions, ...

View full details
Original price $9.99
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price $9.99
Current price $6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99
Sold out

Papa Boi

Heartbreaking Dawns
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99
Out of stock

An absolutely delicious Caribbean-style sauce made with Red Scotch Bonnet peppers, papaya, and mustard. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Papaya, Dis...

View full details
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99
Sold out

Riff Lord

Heartbreaking Dawns
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99
In stock

Heartbreaking Dawns Riff Lord is a tasty mellow sauce made with Red Jalapeño peppers, mustard seed, and onion. This is a very versatile and well ba...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99

Ritual Habitual

Hellfire Hot Sauce
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99
In stock

A magical mix of oranges, mangos, papayas, pineapples, peaches, ginger, vanilla & curry all combined to bring you this amazingly sweet and deli...

View full details
Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
Original price
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
Current price $9.99

Secret Aardvark

Secret Aardvark Trading Co
Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99
Current price $5.99
$5.99 - $5.99
Current price $5.99
In stock

Secret Aardvark is a flavorful sauce made in Portland, Oregon. It is a Caribbean/Tex-mex fusion made with Habaneros, roasted tomato, mustard, carro...

View full details
Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99
Current price $5.99
$5.99 - $5.99
Current price $5.99
Save 14% Save %

Small Axe Peppers Habanero Ginger

Small Axe Peppers
Original price $8.99 - Original price $8.99
Original price
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
Current price $8.99
In stock

This sauce is made with peppers sourced from community gardens and urban farms in cities across the United States, including San Diego, Tucson, Pho...

View full details
Original price $8.99 - Original price $8.99
Original price
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
Current price $8.99

Smoked Habanero Barbeque

Marshall's Haute Sauce
Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
Original price
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
Current price $11.99
Out of stock

A deliciously smoky sauce made with Habanero peppers and comforting flavors like cinnamon, clove and bee local honey.  Heat Level: Mild Ingredient...

View full details
Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
Original price
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
Current price $11.99
Sold out

Smoked Maple Ghost Pepper Mustard

Parker's Gourmet
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99
In stock

A fiery and flavorful mustard made with Smoked Vermont Maple Syrup, that tastes delicious on burgers and hot dogs or as a dip for pretzels.  Heat L...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99

Son of Zombie Wing Sauce

Torchbearer Sauces
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99
Low stock

A delicious creamy wing sauce made with honey, onions, molasses, & a nice kick from Ghost and Habanero peppers.  Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredie...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99

The Chicago Hot Sauce

Small Axe Peppers
Original price $8.99 - Original price $8.99
Original price
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
Current price $8.99
Out of stock

This sauce features the flavors of a classic Chicago Dog, with celery seed, dill, and pickle-y apple cider vinegar, combined with yellow mustard, t...

View full details
Original price $8.99 - Original price $8.99
Original price
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
Current price $8.99
Sold out