Non-5picks

A flavor-forward Caribbean hot sauce featuring fresh papaya and Scotch Bonnet chile peppers, along with onion, olive oil, and garlic. Heat Level: M...

A recipe developed in homage to a Peruvian dish called “Seco" featuring fresh cilantro, spices, garlic, onions, and chili peppers to create the per...

One of our mildest sauces, featuring a nice sweet flavor that works well as a glaze and pairs well with Asian foods. Heat Level: Very Mild Ingredie...

A painfully hot blend of 30% pure Ghost pepper, 30% pure Chocolate Habanero pepper, with carrots and mandarin oranges to round it out.  Heat Level:...

Benito's Reaper Maple Syrup is made with certified organic dark robust Vermont maple syrup and Carolina Reaper peppers. Try on your favorite brea...

Poto Rojo Hot Sauce is made with Carolina Reapers, certified organic Sicilian blood orange juice, fresh onions, carrots and sweet peppers. The resu...

Revved Up Peri-Peri Ghost Sauce is a unique and flavorful hot sauce with sweet and spicy undertones. Ghost, Peri-Peri and Cayenne peppers combine t...

A bright verde sauce, made with onions, cilantro, citrus, banana, and a mix of Serrano and Jalapeño peppers. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Onions, ...

A flavorful blend of tropical fruits like pineapple, mango, and lime, along with Jamaican Scotch Bonnet peppers and mustard. Some allspice and carr...

An even hotter version of Elijah's Extreme Regret, made with Carolina Reaper, Scorpion, and Habanero peppers, along with just a pinch of tomato, pa...

To build your own box, simply pick 1, 3, 6, or 12 bottles and add them to your cart along with this box. Order multiple boxes if you'd like to spli...

Red Reaper is a tasty sauce made with Carolina Reaper, Red Habanero and Cayenne Peppers. It has a slow building heat that builds to a serious burn....

Old Coy Dog is made with organically grown pickled Bhut Jolokia peppers (also known as Ghost Peppers), along with onions, carrots, and fresh lime j...

A garlic lovers dream, this sauce combines a classic tomato base with boat loads of roasted garlic, along with Smoked Ghost peppers for a solid kic...

This sauce is made with ginger, pear and a hint of star anise, with searing heat from yellow Fatalii peppers and 7 Pot Primo peppers. Heat Level: E...

A fiery blend of Reaper, Habanero, Ghost, and Thai chiles, balanced out with fresh mango and citrus juices to provide sweetness and tang.  Heat Lev...

Cerberus, the “Hound of Hades”, is a combination of Trinidad Douglah, Reaper and 7-Pot Primo peppers. This three headed monster will devour your t...

Splash Down to flavor town with the new Thai curry inspired hot sauce from Karma Sauce! Coconut, basil, lemongrass, and lime juice converge to crea...

  Three King's Sauce is a very spicy but flavorful sauce, made with Ghost, Reaper and Scorpion peppers, along with hibiscus flower, brown sugar, an...

Naga Jolokia and Habanero peppers double the peppery pleasure of this garlicky hot sauce. Things get juiced up even more with carrot, lime, onion, ...

A unique blend of hand selected superhot peppers with overtones of savory cinnamon goodness. Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredients: Peppers (ghost, hab...

Torchbearer's second collaboration with Danny Wood and Woodworks brings you Guac Sizzle! This amazing blend of avocado and jalapeño peppers gives y...

Beet N Fresno is made with a perfect balance of sweet and heat, combining beets and fresno peppers for a medium-kick. Heat Level: Medium Ingredient...

They're known for their extreme sauces, but for this sauce Elijah's Xtreme took inspiration from their favorite mild sauces, creating a flavor focu...

The Datil pepper has been cultivated in St Augustine for well over a century, and it's aromatic, fruity flavor is paired nicely with citrus juices ...

This unique sauce starts with a touch of sweetness and a cinnamon burst and then the heat from the Habanero and Peach Ghost Peppers creeps in and i...

This sauce starts with fresh pineapple that has been roasted to caramelize the sugars, which compliments the fiery smoked ghost peppers and spice b...

This gift set is designed for foodies who love trying exciting new ingredients and flavor combinations.  Leche de Tigre Pepper Sauce La Pimenterie...

Like the pied piper, Brother Bru-Bru (Bruce Langhorne) played his gigantic Turkish tambourine as he walked through the streets of New York’s 1960’s...

A classic sriracha style sauce, made with both fresh and smoked garlic for a delicious twist. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Red Jalapeño Mash (pe...

Another delicious sauce from Mikey V, with an excellent balance of Carolina Reaper heat, and plenty of savory garlic, tomato, and onion flavor. Hea...

A ghostly Thai-style sauce, with fragrant shallots, galangal, Kaffir lime leaves, and lemongrass, the tang of fermented kombucha, and plenty of Gho...

A totally unique sauce made with Habanero and Guerro peppers, along with fermented kombucha for a unique tang, and pineapple juice to add a tropica...