Skip to content
Flat Rate $5.99 Shipping + Free Shipping on Gift Sets & Subscriptions
Free Shipping on Gift Sets & Subscriptions

Non-5picks

Filters

Ultimate Mellow Gift Set

Gift Set
$108.99 - $108.99
$108.99
Free Shipping
$108.99 - $108.99
$108.99
In stock

11 delicious sauces ranging from mild to medium in heat level. A great gift for someone who prefers flavor over heat.  The Funk of 40K Years Every...

View full details
$108.99 - $108.99
$108.99
Free Shipping
$108.99 - $108.99
$108.99
Peace & Curry Hot Sauce - Heat

Peace & Curry Hot Sauce

Angry Goat Pepper Co.
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

Peaches, Scotch Bonnets, Fatalii chiles and curry give this sauce a silky smooth, slightly sweet, and zen like kick of citrus and heat. Try on pret...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Tia Lupita Habanero Hot Sauce - Heat

Tia Lupita Habanero Hot Sauce

Tia Lupita
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

Handmade, in small batches, using just a few all natural ingredients, including habanero peppers, dates, mangos and spices. All ingredients are sou...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Clark & Hopkins Chesapeake Bay - Heat

Clark & Hopkins Chesapeake Bay

Clark & Hopkins
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Low stock

A bold blend of spices, apple cider vinegar, bay leaves, Jalapeños, mustard, and ginger. Great with seafood! Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Apple Ci...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Volcano Dust Cajun Spice Blend - Heat

Volcano Dust Cajun Spice Blend

Volcanic Peppers
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

Great tasting all purpose spice blend with Cayenne pepper for a touch of heat, great on chicken and seafood. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Spices,...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Volcanic Mild Taco Sauce - Heat

Volcanic Mild Taco Sauce

Volcanic Peppers
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
In stock

A flavorful mild tomato-based taco sauce made with red peppers, garlic, and onion. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Tomato, Vinegar, Red Chile Peppers...

View full details
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
Rocoto Pepper Grinder

Rocoto Pepper Grinder

Heat Hot Sauce Shop
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
In stock

A glass grinder jar full of Rocoto pepper flakes, a Peruvian pepper known for its black seeds. The subtle medium-heat pairs perfectly with roast ch...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Volcano Dust .5 - Heat

Volcano Dust .5

Volcanic Peppers
$5.99 - $5.99
$5.99
$5.99 - $5.99
$5.99
In stock

A milder version of the classic Volcano Dust, made with a unique blend of heirloom peppers. The Cayenne is smoked, but the rest of the peppers are ...

View full details
$5.99 - $5.99
$5.99
$5.99 - $5.99
$5.99
Estela A Humada

Estela A Humada

Chile Lengua de Fuego
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
In stock

A smoked salsa verde sauce made with Jalapeno and Scotch Bonnet chiles, green pimento, red onion, and rounded out with garlic and thyme. Delicious ...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Bad Karma

Bad Karma

Karma Sauce
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

Bad Karma is a kicked up version of Good Karma, with Habaneros to provide the extra heat, along with the classic base of butternut squash, honey, a...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Tiger Shark Ghost Pepper - Heat

Tiger Shark Ghost Pepper

The Spicy Shark
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

The Tiger Shark is known for its diverse diet and distinguished markings. This fruit forward hot sauce pairs the sweetness of mango, pineapple, and...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Thunder Juice Hot Sauce - Heat
Sold out

Thunder Juice Hot Sauce

High River Sauces
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Out of stock

Thunder Juice features tequila-infused Chocolate Bhutlah and Carolina Reaper peppers rounded out with blueberries and peaches, for a serious kick w...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Sold out
All In - Heat

All In

Rising Smoke Sauceworks
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

A fiery blend of smoked Carolina Reaper, Ghost Pepper, smoked Habanero and Cayenne peppers, along with red wine vinegar, tomatoes, basil, oregano, ...

View full details
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Jalapeno Cucumber - Hella Hot Hot Sauce Heat Hot Sauce Shop

Jalapeño Cucumber

Hella Hot Hot Sauce
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

A refreshing blend of jalapeños and cucumbers, with lemon juice, shallots, coriander and a secret blend of herbs.  Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Cu...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Huhū Diablo

Huhū Diablo

Karma Sauce
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
In stock

A hotter take on the classic Huhū Piña sauce, this sauce still features fresh pineapple front and center, but 7 Pot Primo peppers provide a serious...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Fire Truck - Heat

Fire Truck

J's Small Batch Hot Sauce
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Low stock

A flavor forward habanero sauce, with a smoky twist from applewood smoked sea salt. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Water, Vinegar (distilled, apple c...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Mako Snake Hot Sauce - Heat

Mako Snake Hot Sauce

The Spicy Shark
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

The Mako Snake is the second mythical creature to join the 6-Fin Series. Like the ghost pepper that is featured in this sauce, the Mako Snake is in...

View full details
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Hellfire Detroit Bourbon Habanero Ghost - Heat

Hellfire Detroit Bourbon Habanero Ghost

Hellfire Detroit
$18.99 - $18.99
$18.99
$18.99 - $18.99
$18.99
In stock

An oaky bourbon and fire-roasted habanero hot sauce, with an extra kick from smoked ghost chile powder and bold cider vinegar and lime acidity. Hea...

View full details
$18.99 - $18.99
$18.99
$18.99 - $18.99
$18.99
Serrano Bullwhip - Heat

Serrano Bullwhip

Barnacle Foods
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

Bullwhip is made with Alaskan bull kelp as the first ingredient, giving it a rich creamy consistency and a blast of umami flavor. Fiery Serrano pe...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Danny Wood's Jalapeño Cilantro Sauce - Heat

Danny Wood's Jalapeño Cilantro Sauce

Torchbearer Sauces
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

The folks at Torchbearer Sauces teamed up with musician and The Wood Works creator and chef, Danny Wood, to create this delicious mild jalapeño sau...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Volcano Dust Spicy Chili Powder - Heat

Volcano Dust Spicy Chili Powder

Volcanic Peppers
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

Ancho, Jalapeño, Cayenne and smoked Habanero blended with garlic, onion and fine herbs and spices makes this a great compliment to your chili recip...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Slow Death - Heat

Slow Death

Rising Smoke Sauceworks
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
In stock

A fiery blend of Trinidad Scorpion peppers and smoked Habanero, along with tomato, red onion, and garlic. Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredients: Water,...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Cosmic Disco

Cosmic Disco

Karma Sauce
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

A mash up of two of Karma’s most popular hot sauces - Cosmic Dumpling and Scorpion Disco. From Cosmic Dumpling comes the incredible Asian flavors, ...

View full details
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
The Bird Blood - Heat

The Bird Blood

Sauce Leopard
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

Toss your grandma's cranberry sauce in the trash and make room for Bird Blood at the table. Perfect for a festive poultry feast, this sauce will fi...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99

Ritual Hot Sauce

Hellfire Hot Sauce
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

A taste of the islands with a serious kick. Hellfire layers mango, papaya, pineapple, mandarin orange, and peach with exotic spices and a splash of...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
The Seventh Reaper - Heat

The Seventh Reaper

Sauce Leopard
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

A unique take on an Argentinian red chimichurri, made with tomato, parsley, cilantro, and green onion.  Jalapeños and Carolina Reapers provide a ki...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
La Pistola - Heat

La Pistola

Paulman Acre & J's Small Batch
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Low stock

A unique collaboration between Paulman Acre and J's Small Batch featuring smoked strawberries, crafted with just the right amount of heat, sweetnes...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Ancho Masala Scorpion Reaper - Heat

Ancho Masala Scorpion Reaper

Bravado Spice Co.
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

An explosive trinity of ultra hot peppers; with a blend of delicious Indian spices & Texas flair. Tread lightly, Ancho Masala Scorpion-Reaper H...

View full details
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Ghost Truffle - Heat

Ghost Truffle

Ghost Scream
$17.99 - $17.99
$17.99
$17.99 - $17.99
$17.99
In stock

Do you value flavor more than heat? Then you’ll love Ghost Scream Ghost Truffle Hot Sauce. This sauce is full of savory spices and fresh ingredient...

View full details
$17.99 - $17.99
$17.99
$17.99 - $17.99
$17.99
It’s Tuesday Somewhere

It’s Tuesday Somewhere

Karma Sauce
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

Taco Tuesday isn't a day of the week, it's a state of mind. And nothing will get you in the right headspace quicker than this award-winning taco sa...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Taco Vibes Only
Save 14% Save %

Taco Vibes Only

Butterfly Bakery
$14.00
$14.00 - $14.00
$14.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

Taco Vibes Only is a vibrant, painfully joyous hot sauce that will bring those tasty taco vibes to the table. It's a stealthy sauce that starts out...

View full details
$14.00
$14.00 - $14.00
$14.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Save 14% Save %
Torchbearer Goblin Sauce - Heat

Torchbearer Goblin Sauce

Torchbearer Sauces
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
In stock

A delicious collaboration with the band Nekrogoblikon, made with Jalapeño and Trinidad Scorpion Peppers, along with pineapple, orange juice, and bl...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Volcanic Peppers Hot Taco Sauce - Heat

Volcanic Peppers Hot Taco Sauce

Volcanic Peppers
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
In stock

This is a tomato based taco sauce with the same great flavor as Volcanic Peppers Mild Taco Sauce but with the added heat of Trinidad Scorpion and G...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Bad News Reaper - Heat

Bad News Reaper

Infinity Sauces
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
In stock

Stimulate your palate with this amazing sauce that provides big flavors while delivering an aggressive amount of heat. The addictively complex flav...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
The Emerald Slime - Heat

The Emerald Slime

Sauce Leopard
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
In stock

The Emerald Slime, lord of the verde sauces. Refreshingly bright and perfect with breakfast. Roasted tomatillos, an ideal balance of Jalapeño and S...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Mikey V's Dill Pickle Jalapeño - Heat

Mikey V's Dill Pickle Jalapeño

Mikey V's
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

The perfect crossover for the pickle lovers out there, this sauce combines fresh Jalapeño peppers and garlic with tangy dill pickles, perfect for s...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99