Non-5picks
Ultimate Hot Sauce Tasting Gift Set
Gift SetA wide array of delicious small batch hot sauces, perfect for throwing your own hot sauce tasting party. From mild sauces great for cooking with, t...
View full detailsPepper North Black Cherry & Reaper
Pepper North Artisan Foods5.0 / 5.0
2 Reviews
Pairing Carolina reaper peppers with black cherries, Canadian apple cider and fresh garlic, this sauce is the perfect complement to your chicken wi...
View full detailsSmoked Habanero Pepper Grinder
Heat Hot Sauce Shop4.96 / 5.0
26 Reviews
A grinder full of Smoked Habanero peppers, with a solid kick and a bold smoky flavor. Amazing on pizza. See our other pepper grinders here. Heat L...
View full detailsAleppo Pepper Grinder
Heat Hot Sauce Shop5.0 / 5.0
1 Review
A glass grinder jar full of Aleppo Chile flakes, an earthy pepper that originated in Syria. Try grinding some into hummus. See our other pepper gri...
View full detailsRosalila Fire
Chile Lengua de Fuego5.0 / 5.0
1 Review
A classic Honduran Scotch Bonnet sauce, with pepper flavor front and center and a tomato, carrot, and Vidalia onion base. Heat Level: Hot Ingredien...
View full details7o8 7 Pot Citrus
Heat Hot Sauce Shop4.69 / 5.0
107 Reviews
After Bigfat's closed up shop a few years ago, we've gotten hundreds of requests for 7o8. After chatting with Jeremy Walsh, the creator of this inc...
View full detailsNo Kid Hungry Gift Set
Gift SetA set of 6 unique, flavor-forward hot sauces, put together to raise money for No Kid Hungry. Every set purchased funds 60 meals for hungry kids! Th...
View full detailsAardvark Reaper
Secret Aardvark Trading Co4.43 / 5.0
7 Reviews
The heat intensity will wake up your tastebuds but won’t melt your face! Well, maybe just a little. This is not a vinegar forward sauce, Aardvark ...
View full detailsLow Sodium Hot Sauce 6-Pack
Gift SetAll of these sauces are full of flavor, but light on the sodium, with no more than 30 mg a serving. Plus they highlight a wide variety of flavors a...
View full detailsRare Pepper Grinder Duo
Heat Hot Sauce Shop4.6 / 5.0
10 Reviews
Two of our newest hot pepper grinders, made with rare chiles you won't find elsewhere. The Aji Charapita is a much sought after Peruvian chile, wit...
View full detailsMystery Bottle of Hot Sauce
Heat4.67 / 5.0
6 Reviews
Not sure what to pick? We'll choose for you! Feel free to let us know in the order notes if there are general flavors or heat levels you like.
Mikey V's Hot Chip Sauce
Mikey V'sIt had to be done. A hot sauce made with actual hot chips! Tangy, zesty, and hot, with the classic bright red color, try it on Mexican street corn,...
View full detailsBerry Curry
Chile Lengua de Fuego5.0 / 5.0
2 Reviews
Berries and curry sound like an odd mashup, but the folks at Chile Lengua de Fuego found a way to make it work, with blackberry, pineapple, and man...
View full detailsCarolina Reaper Powder
Heat Hot Sauce Shop5.0 / 5.0
9 Reviews
A pure and simple powder made from 100% Carolina Reapers. Extremely spicy, so handle with caution. Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredients: Carolina Reap...
View full details7 Pot Primo Powder
Heat Hot Sauce Shop5.0 / 5.0
3 Reviews
A extremely hot powder made from 100% 7 Pot Primo Peppers. This is one of the hottest peppers in the world, so handle with caution. Heat Level: Ext...
View full detailsFatalii Pepper Powder
Heat Hot Sauce ShopPure powdered Fatalii peppers, known for the bright citrusy flavor and intense but not overwhelming heat. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Fatalii Pepp...
View full detailsHabanero Pepper Powder
Heat Hot Sauce ShopWe sourced a particularly tasty variety of habaneros grown in the Yucatan, with a rich roasty flavor and moderate kick. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients...
View full detailsZab's Original
Zab's2.5 / 5.0
2 Reviews
A twist on a classic vinegar based hot sauce, featuring the Datil pepper, along with organic carrots, onions, garlic, and a touch of spices. Heat L...
View full detailsZab's St. Augustine Style
Zab's5.0 / 5.0
1 Review
A sweeter and fruitier version of the original Zab's, featuring the Datil pepper, pineapple, cider vinegar, and a blend of spices. Heat Level: Medi...
View full detailsMustard Dill Scorpion
Tennessee Hot Sauce Co5.0 / 5.0
1 Review
A bold combination of zesty mustard, crisp dill pickles, fiery Scorpion Peppers, and the delightful smokiness of smoked paprika. Heat Level: Extra ...
View full detailsMustard Glen Hot Sauce
J's Small Batch Hot SauceIn Scotland the Glen is said to be the best part of the river which is why "Glen" so commonly becomes the namesake of distilleries in the region. T...
View full detailsJ's Fermented Taco
J's Small Batch Hot SauceVelvet smooth texture from the avocado oil complements the fermented Mexican chilis and Extra Anejo Tequila to truly give this sauce a spot on the...
View full detailsSmoke A Peach
Paulman Acre“Smoke a Peach” is a limited release that combines apple smoked habaneros and peaches with fresh Southern California loquats. The result is a mash-...
View full detailsSUK Mango Serrano Hot Sauce
Volcanic Peppers5.0 / 5.0
1 Review
A bright and tangy sauce with fresh mangos and Serrano peppers front and center, with a backdrop of Red Bell peppers and citrus. Heat Level: Medium...
View full details