Non-5picks

Bloodroot Mountain's most traditional sauce, built around Vermont-grown cayenne peppers and fire-roasted red bell peppers for that classic red hot ...

To anyone who thinks sweet hot sauces cannot bring the heat, Plum Reaper begs to differ. Carolina Reapers and sweet plums are bottled together for ...

High River fuses the unrelenting heat of Pepper X with fire-roasted tomatoes, garlic, cumin and lime juice. The flavor hits first with a rich roast...

An all-natural collaboration with Chocolate Skateboards, this rich and unexpected sauce layers blackberries, raisins, molasses, cocoa and cinnamon ...

Yellowbird's Serrano Coconut, sold for years as Bliss and Vinegar, is a small batch sauce built on ripe red serrano peppers, fresh strawberries, an...

Yellowbird's Hatch Tahini is a small batch sauce that pairs the bright, floral flavor of New Mexico Hatch chiles with sweet onions and nutty tahini...

From Cain's Hot Sauce in Austin, Texas, Caribe puts fiery Scotch Bonnet peppers front and center. Mustard, turmeric, and garlic build a tangy, gold...

A tropical, fruit-forward hot sauce that leads with sweet pineapple. Mango rounds it out while chilies, onion, garlic, and island spices keep it sa...

Taffy Shop's Taf-Fuego packs four spicy-sweet salt water taffy flavors into a 7 oz bag. Each soft, chewy piece blends bright fruit and sweet candy ...

For the dad who wants to kick the heat up without sacrificing flavor. Truffle Fire layers earthy gourmet truffle over a smooth burn, our own Roaste...

The everyday lineup every dad should have on the table. Funky's Pieno Di Stelle is a Calabrian-chili Italian hot sauce, The Clasico is a balanced, ...

Send Dad on a flavor vacation without leaving the backyard. Cain's Caribe brings bright, fruity Caribbean-style heat, Mamas Peri Peri Medium Heat d...

A trio of rare superhot pepper grinders for the dad who likes to play with fire: Naga Viper, Dragon's Breath, and Bhutlah. Grind fresh over anythin...

A trio of everyday pepper grinders for the dad who seasons everything. Smoked Habanero adds smoky warmth, Peri Peri brings bright, tangy heat, and ...

The only thing cheesier than dad jokes are these three fiery popcorn seasonings. Habanero White Cheddar Seasoning, Chipotle Ghost Nacho Cheese Seas...

Three flavor-boosting seasonings to upgrade everything Dad cooks. Ghost Pepper Salt & Vinegar Seasoning brings a tangy, spicy kick, the Ghost A...