Non-5picks

Coleman’s hottest offering yet, this sauce puts the heat and flavor of the Carolina Reaper on full display, with a classic backdrop of vinegar and ...

Apple Caraway is balanced with sweetness from dates and apple, fresh pepper flavor, and the depth of caraway. It's a great medium heat sauce with a...

Get a taste of San Diego with this rich, smoky Chipotle sauce. The mellow kick is paired with plenty of garlic and rounded out with a vinegar tang....

Delicious crunchy cheese puffs coated in zesty lemon, cracked pepper, and one of the world’s hottest peppers. The heat is intense and unrelenting—t...

Crunchy almonds coated in sharp cheddar and smoky ghost pepper seasoning. The flavor is rich and savory with a slow-building heat that adds a satis...

These handcrafted candies are bursting with the sweet and tangy flavor of blood oranges, giving way to a surprise center of chili, lime, and sea sa...

A luxurious, extra spicy Indian-inspired sauce, with a creamy coconut base and Ghost & Habanero heat. Apricot and maple syrup add a hint of swe...

This Thai-inspired sauce fuses the fierce bite of Bird’s Eye, Ghost, and Carolina Reaper peppers into a creamy green curry base. Coconut milk softe...

Crunchy cheese puffs coated in a flavorful blend of creamy ranch and habanero heat.  Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Cheese Balls: Corn Meal, Veget...

This sauce is similar to Torchbearer’s cult-favorite Garlic Reaper but without the overwhelming heat. Its creamy base pairs well with the bold garl...

A smoky chipotle and garlic sauce created in collaboration with the chart-topping rock band Shinedown, named for their hit "A Symptom of Being Huma...