Non-5picks

A slightly spicy, totally luscious dulce de leche caramel with nuttiness of pecans and a subtly smoky kick. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Milk, Sug...

A small sample of Smoked Ghost Pepper flakes.

A flavorful blend of Smoked Habanero peppers along with toasted cumin, garlic, toasted onion, and Mexican oregano to create the perfect sodium-free...

A bold blend of Thai chile flakes, galangal, and kaffir lime leaves to create the perfect compliment to curries, fried rice, or stir frys. See our ...

A versatile blend of organic black pepper, warming ginger, and fiery Peri Peri chiles, delivering a bright, aromatic heat that lifts everything fro...

This fiery mustard hot sauce blends yellow and black mustard with the earthy depth of black cardamom, while smoked Reapers and Yellow 7 Pot peppers...

A blend of zesty lemon pepper, sweet mustard, smooth garlic, and hot Datil and Savina peppers, creating a sauce that is at home on anything from ho...

A true taste of Montana, blending fresh Flathead Lake cherries and a touch of local honey with fire-roasted Habaneros and the deep smokiness of Chi...

A surprisingly hot Ghost Pepper sauce made in Canada, with rich smoky notes balanced with Sriracha style sweetness. Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredien...

This rich, hickory-smoked sauce blends fresh pears with the slow burn of Ghost peppers. The heat isn’t overwhelming, but it lingers on the palate. ...

This sauce caught our eye for its vegetable-broth base, which provides a rich umami flavor complemented by smoked sweet onions, chipotle chiles, an...

This limited-run version of the classic To The Moon sauce features the rare SB7J chile pepper, a cross between a Jonah 7 Pot and a Scotch Bonnet. C...

A good sauce doesn’t always need an exciting label, it’s what’s inside that counts. This one is chock full of flavor, with tomatoes, garlic, onion,...

BullHeaded is a Smoked Serrano and Urfa sauce, with a touch of Habanero for a hearty kick. The Urfa is an earthy, fruity chile from Turkey, and add...

This sauce brings together a tangy vinegar base with Cayenne and Habanero peppers for a solid everyday kick. The unique addition of radishes adds a...

A passion for heat and a dedication to preserving time-honored traditions fostered a perfect marriage between Primo's Peppers & The Farmer's Da...

Dawson’s Coffee Date Hot Sauce blends sweet dates, subtle coffee notes, and pomegranate molasses with a touch of habanero for very mild hea...

A classic red hot sauce from the Stanky Brothers, crafted with Chile de Arbol, Red Jalapeños, and key lime juice for an everyday flavor adventure. ...

A bourbon infused spicy waffle topper crafted in collaboration with Sweet As Waffles in Bellingham, WA. Made with ghost pepper, maple syrup from Mi...

A deep, sweet, and seriously spicy BBQ-style sauce from Bellingham, WA. Dark Star pairs Carolina Reaper and Ghost Pepper with cherries, brown sugar...

A follow-up to the wildly popular XX Salsa Vibes collaboration between High Desert Sauce Co and Craving Capsaicin, this time with *double* the pepp...

A smoky chipotle and garlic sauce created in collaboration with the chart-topping rock band Shinedown, named for their hit "A Symptom of Being Huma...

High River fuses the unrelenting heat of Pepper X with fire-roasted tomatoes, garlic, cumin and lime juice. The flavor hits first with a rich roast...