Non-5picks

This award winning Vermont-crafted sauce blends Fatalii, Habanero, and Paper Lantern peppers for a sharp, citrusy heat. Carrots add a subtle sweetn...

BullHeaded is a Smoked Serrano and Urfa sauce, with a touch of Habanero for a hearty kick. The Urfa is an earthy, fruity chile from Turkey, and add...

Vandal Sauce is a Pacific-Northwest classic, and this edition brings it to the next level with the distinctive flavor and fiery heat of Trinidad Sc...

Beautiful Buena Mulata and Sweet Purple Heirloom peppers are the stars of this sauce, bringing an extra depth of flavor to a classic vinegar-forwar...

Known for its distinctive, bumpy shape that resembles a brain, the 7 Pot Brain Strain pepper brings some intense heat along with a subtle tropical ...

This creamy, Denver-crafted sauce is rooted in an old Portuguese family recipe, with extra Peri Peri peppers to showcase their bright, citrusy bite...

This creamy, Denver-crafted sauce is rooted in an old Portuguese family recipe, showcasing the bright, citrusy bite of Peri Peri peppers balanced w...

An upgraded version of the northwest classic Vandal Pepper Sauce, with deep, earthy chile de arbol and fruity red serrano balanced by bright lemon ...

A classic blend of mustard, mango, and habanero peppers with a balance of tangy, sweet, and mild heat. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Water, Musta...

This sauce brings together a tangy vinegar base with Cayenne and Habanero peppers for a solid everyday kick. The unique addition of radishes adds a...

A passion for heat and a dedication to preserving time-honored traditions fostered a perfect marriage between Primo's Peppers & The Farmer's Da...

This sauce is similar to Torchbearer’s cult-favorite Garlic Reaper but without the overwhelming heat. Its creamy base pairs well with the bold garl...

Dawson’s Coffee Date Hot Sauce blends sweet dates, subtle coffee notes, and pomegranate molasses with a touch of habanero for very mild hea...

A hot sauce lovechild inspired by the classic table sauces we all know and love, bringing together Chile Pequin, Chile de Arbol, New Mexico Chiles,...

A powerful mix of Carolina Reaper, Ghost Pepper, and Dragon's Breath Pepper Powder that starts with sweet and sour notes before delivering a knocko...

A sweet and spicy sauce from the Stanky Brothers in Florida, blending green Jalapeños with agave nectar and a serious kick from Carolina Reaper pep...

A classic red hot sauce from the Stanky Brothers, crafted with Chile de Arbol, Red Jalapeños, and key lime juice for an everyday flavor adventure. ...

Montana Gold brings next level heat from Yellow Moruga Scorpion peppers combined with grapes and orange juice. It's like a mimosa with a powerful s...

A unique combination of Arbol and Pequin Peppers [to be continued] Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Water, Distilled Vinegar, Annatto Seeds, Garlic,...

Inspired by a traditional brown Mexican mole, this sauce starts with a fermented base of Chocolate Habanero, Morita, and Ancho chiles, balanced wit...

A flavor forward sauce featuring habaneros, carrots, and ginger blended with mango puree and a splash of cider vinegar for a spicy, sweet, tropical...

Stellar Fuzz is a habanero based sauce with garlic & ginger zing. It’s reasonably spicy with a burst of hearty flavor. Try it on curries, samo...

A suped up version of Funky's Liquid Sunshine, kissed by the green fairy. This sweet and spicy habanero sauce is infused with Pacifique absinthe, l...

A tropical habanero and fresno pepper sauce with a healthy dose of sweet pineapple to complement the fruitiness of the peppers and soothe the burn....

Made with three types of red chilies, all aged for approximately one year in used bourbon barrels from Bellingham's own Chuckanut Bay Distillery. T...

Italian for "Full of Stars," this sauce is made with three kinds of Calabrian chilis grown in the Skagit Valley. Perfect on pizza, pasta, and stirr...

The official 1st place winner of the 2022 Screaming MiMi Reaper Sauce category. Carolina Reapers are paired with plums and umeboshi vinegar to brin...

A bourbon infused spicy waffle topper crafted in collaboration with Sweet As Waffles in Bellingham, WA. Made with ghost pepper, maple syrup from Mi...

The sister sauce to Stellar Fuzz, built on a chocolate habanero base with garlic, ginger, goji berries and Fuzz IPA from Structures Brewing in Bell...

A fermented green chili sauce made from four different green chilis. The aged mash of jalapeño, serrano, anaheim and poblano peppers creates a uniq...

A sauce that truly represents the local bounty of the Pacific Northwest. Made with Kraken scorpion peppers, lemongrass and ground cherries from Sou...

A deep, sweet, and seriously spicy BBQ-style sauce from Bellingham, WA. Dark Star pairs Carolina Reaper and Ghost Pepper with cherries, brown sugar...