Non-5picks

Made with three types of red chilies, all aged for approximately one year in used bourbon barrels from Bellingham's own Chuckanut Bay Distillery. T...

Italian for "Full of Stars," this sauce is made with three kinds of Calabrian chilis grown in the Skagit Valley. Perfect on pizza, pasta, and stirr...

The official 1st place winner of the 2022 Screaming MiMi Reaper Sauce category. Carolina Reapers are paired with plums and umeboshi vinegar to brin...

A bourbon infused spicy waffle topper crafted in collaboration with Sweet As Waffles in Bellingham, WA. Made with ghost pepper, maple syrup from Mi...

The sister sauce to Stellar Fuzz, built on a chocolate habanero base with garlic, ginger, goji berries and Fuzz IPA from Structures Brewing in Bell...

A fermented green chili sauce made from four different green chilis. The aged mash of jalapeño, serrano, anaheim and poblano peppers creates a uniq...

A sauce that truly represents the local bounty of the Pacific Northwest. Made with Kraken scorpion peppers, lemongrass and ground cherries from Sou...

Sour watermelon gummies drenched in tangy chamoy sauce and dusted with chili powder. Every bite hits sweet, sour, salty, and spicy all at once. A c...

This flavorful BBQ sauce has cleaned up at the chilehead award shows, winning 1st place at Zest Fest, the NYC Hot Sauce Expo, and the Fiery Food Sh...

It's a Northwest twist on our original recipe. Marionberry blackberries from Oregon add a nice round complexity to the flavor of this sauce. Espec...

A jammy, slow-sipping hot sauce built on fermented Fresno peppers, coffee kombucha, and Oak and Bond coffee. Black currants, dark sweet cherries, p...

A vinegar-forward sauce built for pure heat. Ground Trinidad Scorpion pepper hits hard, with garlic and cayenne rounding it out. Simple, direct, an...

A follow-up to the wildly popular XX Salsa Vibes collaboration between High Desert Sauce Co and Craving Capsaicin, this time with *double* the pepp...

This stealthy scorcher leads with super-hot Trinidad Moruga Scorpion peppers as its very first ingredient, so the heat is no joke. Lime juice, onio...

Bloodroot Mountain's most traditional sauce, built around Vermont-grown cayenne peppers and fire-roasted red bell peppers for that classic red hot ...

To anyone who thinks sweet hot sauces cannot bring the heat, Plum Reaper begs to differ. Carolina Reapers and sweet plums are bottled together for ...

High River fuses the unrelenting heat of Pepper X with fire-roasted tomatoes, garlic, cumin and lime juice. The flavor hits first with a rich roast...

An all-natural collaboration with Chocolate Skateboards, this rich and unexpected sauce layers blackberries, raisins, molasses, cocoa and cinnamon ...

From Cain's Hot Sauce in Austin, Texas, Caribe puts fiery Scotch Bonnet peppers front and center. Mustard, turmeric, and garlic build a tangy, gold...

A tropical, fruit-forward hot sauce that leads with sweet pineapple. Mango rounds it out while chilies, onion, garlic, and island spices keep it sa...