Non-5picks

A very special limited edition sauce from Pex, made with fiery fresh Scorpion peppers along with bright raspberries.  Heat Level: Extreme Ingredien...

A blend of peaches, tomatillos, carrots, and  onions, with plenty of tangy lime juice, and a mixture of Scotch Bonnet and Red Carolina Reaper for a...

Celebrate the life of a very special dog by unleashing the bold, earthy fury of Elder's Revenge. Packed with the legendary heat of the 7 Pot Primo,...

Mango & banana are combined to bring forth a tropical flair that complements the heat from Scotch Bonnet peppers. Vinegar and lime juice contri...

Sweet, salty & garlicky! All the elements of a traditional Sriracha with that added heat of habanero peppers. This hot sauce is ideal for those...

The distinct flavors of tomato, carrot and Ancho chilies combined with cumin, smoked paprika and lime juice sets the stage for this flavor bomb. Th...

Garlic Cilantro Jalapeño is a robust and flavorful sauce that brings together the aromatic punch of garlic, the brightness of cilantro, tanginess o...

Made with fresh lime, cilantro, jalapeño and habanero, this hot sauce adds the spirit of the Southwest to any dish. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients...

The word Ponzu means “Vinegar Punch” in Japanese. The combination of soy sauce, citrus, ginger, garlic and hot peppers makes this a great sauce to ...

5 whole dried Carolina Reaper pods. Can you handle the heat? Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredients: Carolina Reaper Peppers. 5 peppers

5 whole dried Ghost Pepper pods. Can you handle the heat? Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredients: Ghost Peppers. 5 peppers

Flavorful and bright, Thai chile powder provides a solid kick up front that fades quicky. Incredible added to soups and curries. Heat Level: Medium...

An incredibly flavorful and complex chile powder, Chiltepins are a tiny berry-like chile pepper that thrive in arid deserts of the American Southwe...

Pure Yellow Moruga Scorpion in powder form. This is an underrated pepper with some serious heat and awesome flavor! Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredien...

A glass grinder jar full of Orange Habanero pepper flakes. A classic pepper with solid heat that tastes great on pizza. See our other pepper grinde...

The flavors of smoky chipotle peppers, cocoa, and coffee harmonize nicely with a sweetness from pineapple and aromatics like garlic, onion, and gin...

Double Take's sweet and spicy signature sauce, featuring a base of roasted red bell peppers, carrots, and onion, with a pepper blend of Ancho, Haba...

A well balanced Louisiana style sauce made with Orange Habanero and Cayenne peppers, along with distilled and white wine vinegar for plenty of tang...

A multi-award winning take on soy sauce, with a medium kick and a delicious twist of sweetness. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Soy Sauce (water, w...

An incredible collaboration from High Desert Sauce Co and Craving Capsaicin, this sauce blends fire roasted tomatoes with Habanero, Reaper, and Jal...

Coleman’s hottest offering yet, this sauce puts the heat and flavor of the Carolina Reaper on full display, with a classic backdrop of vinegar and ...

Coleman’s mildest sauce, it features the clean flavor of Cayenne peppers front and center, with plenty of tang from white wine vinegar and lemon ju...

Apple Caraway is balanced with sweetness from dates and apple, fresh pepper flavor, and the depth of caraway. It's a great medium heat sauce with a...

A spooky combination of Ghost, Cayenne, and Red Habaneros, with plenty of garlic and a secret blend of Cajun spices to round it out.  Heat Level: E...

A flavor bomb inspired by the bold kick of Chinese take-out mustard. This blend amplifies the heat and intensity, delivering a fiery punch that wil...

The hottest sauce from Fresco Sauce Co, Arbol Scorpion combines fruity Scorpion peppers, rich pomegranate juice, grassy Arbol chili, and earthy ann...

Mellow Vibes Only Hot Sauce is the milder sibling of Butterfly Bakery's fiery Taco Vibes Only hot sauce. It balances serrano and sweet peppers with...

A blazing upgrade to Gator Jake's Rajun Cajun, this sauce brings in fiery 7-Pot Primo peppers to deliver some serious heat along with the classic C...

Get a taste of San Diego with this rich, smoky Chipotle sauce. The mellow kick is paired with plenty of garlic and rounded out with a vinegar tang....

Created in Oceanside, California, this sauce has a garlic-forward flavor, with smoky hints of Paprika and the slow building heat of Ghost Peppers. ...

Datil peppers are a citrusy yellow pepper known for being grown in St. Augustine, Florida. This sauce combines fermented Datil mash with fresh and ...

An extra garlicy Thai chile sauces crafted in Santa Paula, California by a Thai-American family. Made with fresh carrots and garlic along with the ...

A hotter Thai chile sauces crafted in Santa Paula, California by a Thai-American family. Made with fresh carrot and garlic along with an extra serv...