Skip to content
Flat Rate $5.99 Shipping + Free Shipping on Gift Sets & Subscriptions
Free Shipping on Gift Sets & Subscriptions

Non-5picks

Filters

Fiji Fire - Heat Sold out

Fiji Fire

Fiji Fire
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Out of stock

Fiji Fire features the Bongo Chilli, a delicious habanero with a sweet and fruity taste, that's native to the island of Fiji. It's combined with fr...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Sold out
Maple Rum Chipotle - Heat

Maple Rum Chipotle

Butterfly Bakery
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

Buttery Bakery's Maple Rum Chipotle is a sweet and smoky sauce made with maple wood smoked Jalapeños, maple syrup and maple rum. Heat Level: Mediu...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Volcano Dust 3 - Heat

Volcano Dust 3

Volcanic Peppers
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
In stock

A delicious blend of smoked Bhut Jolokia, dehydrated 7 Pot, Moruga and Trinidad Scorpion peppers. Heat Level: Extra Hot Ingredients: Bhut Jolokia, ...

View full details
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
Thai Chile Pepper Grinder - Heat

Thai Chile Pepper Grinder

Heat Hot Sauce Shop
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
In stock

A grinder jar full of Thai Chile flakes, highlighting the bright punch of these fiery (but still quite manageable) peppers. See our other pepper gr...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
The Subtle Tease - Heat
Sold out

The Subtle Tease

Paulman Acre & J's Small Batch
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Out of stock

A Heat Hot Sauce Shop exclusive, this collaboration between Paulman Acre and J's Small Batch features fermented green chili peppers, Meyer lemons a...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Sold out
Red Chili Lime - Heat

Red Chili Lime

Marshall's Haute Sauce
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
In stock

This sauce is modeled after bento sweet chili sauce, removing corn syrup and including local honey instead. Marshall's Haute Sauce only uses Bee Lo...

View full details
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
Sweet Hotato - Heat

Sweet Hotato

Chile Lengua de Fuego
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

A sweet potato based sauce made in Honduras, with coffee liqueur, passion fruit, and a dash of coriander and cardamom seeds. Note: this sauce was f...

View full details
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Kolohe Kid - Heat

Kolohe Kid

Adoboloco
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
In stock

A tangy, vinegar-forward sauce made with Ghost peppers and Hawaiian chile peppers. Heat Level: Extra Hot (but on the low end of the extra hot spect...

View full details
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
Serrano Ginger Lemongrass Hot Sauce - Heat

Serrano Ginger Lemongrass Hot Sauce

Marshall's Haute Sauce
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
In stock

This unique and flavorful sauce uses citrus to balance the heat of Serrano peppers and bridge the aromatic qualities of ginger and lemongrass.  Hea...

View full details
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
Mikey V's Mild Taco Sauce - Heat

Mikey V's Mild Taco Sauce

Mikey V's
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

A classic taco style sauce, with a tomato base and Mikey V's own taco seasoning (which includes cumin, black pepper, and oregano). Very mellow heat...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Gold 79 - Heat

Gold 79

Burns & McCoy
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

Burns & McCoy Gold 79 is a mild pepper sauce, with a hint of turmeric and mustard that will leave you wanting more.  Heat Level: Mild Ingredie...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Cranky Cranberry Cherry Bomb - Heat

Cranky Cranberry Cherry Bomb

Volcanic Peppers
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

This limited edition sauce is full of Cherry Bomb and Anaheim peppers with whole cranberries. It's the perfect sauce to liven up a holiday meal.  H...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Heartbreaking Dawns Jalapeño Pineapple - Heat

Heartbreaking Dawns Jalapeño Pineapple

Heartbreaking Dawns
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

Heartbreaking Dawn's Jalapeño Pineapple is a fresh and thick sauce with a mild heat level. Try it on pork chops or rice dishes. Heat Level: Mild I...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Heartbreaking Dawns 1841 Ghost Pepper - Heat
Sold out

Heartbreaking Dawns 1841 Ghost Pepper

Heartbreaking Dawns
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Out of stock

Heartbreaking Dawn's 1841 is a delicious blend of Ghost peppers, pears and apples, along with carrots and lime juice. This sauce packs a punch, bu...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Sold out
Marie Sharp's Red Hornet - Heat
Save 22% Save %

Marie Sharp's Red Hornet

Marie Sharp's
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
In stock

A fiery Trinidad Scorpion (aka Red Hornet) pepper sauce, with the classic Marie Sharp's tang. The hottest sauce from Marie Sharp's yet! Heat Level:...

View full details
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
Save 22% Save %
Lucky Dog 10th Anniversary Sauce w/ Drake's Denogginizer IPA - Heat

Lucky Dog 10th Anniversary Sauce w/ Drake's Denogginizer IPA

Lucky Dog Hot Sauce
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

A one of a kind creation to celebrate 10 years of Lucky Dog Hot Sauce, this sauce blends scotch bonnet peppers, alderwood smoked sea salt, blueberr...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Brain Jerk Peri Peri - Heat
Sold out

Brain Jerk Peri Peri

Hella Hot Hot Sauce
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Out of stock

Inspired by Portuguese Piri Piri Sauce (as well as the band Ghoul), this sauce blends African Birds Eye peppers with orange juice, shallots, coconu...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Sold out
Passiflora Fire - Heat
Save 14% Save %

Passiflora Fire

Chile Lengua de Fuego
$14.00
$14.00 - $14.00
$14.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

A unique sauce made in Honduras, with raw passionfruit, smoked scotch bonnets, and a unique spice blend that includes nutmeg and clove.  Heat Level...

View full details
$14.00
$14.00 - $14.00
$14.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Save 14% Save %
Sam Sauce - Heat

Sam Sauce

Mikey V's
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
In stock

Sam Sauce is the product of two chileheads who went a little bit crazy in the kitchen one day. By combining the flavors of Japanese Black Vinegar a...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Good Karma - Heat

Good Karma

Karma Sauce
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
In stock

Good Karma Hot Sauce is a slightly thick butternut squash sauce with the zing of fresh red pepper and a tangy flavor that adds a new dimension in r...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Ghost of Saffron - Heat

Ghost of Saffron

High Desert Sauce Co.
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

A transcendent taco sauce featuring a combination of Scotch Bonnet and Ghost Peppers for a moderate kick, and the rich flavor of roasted garlic, on...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Heady Topper Craft Beer Sauce - Heat

Heady Topper Craft Beer Sauce

Butterfly Bakery
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

Made with the world famous Heady Topper IPA, this medium heat hot sauce is made with green jalapeños and will deliver you right up to hop sauce hea...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Bravado Spice Garlic & Arbol Seasoning - Heat

Bravado Spice Garlic & Arbol Seasoning

Bravado Spice Co.
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

A bold all purpose seasoning made with Arbol chiles. Try on grilled steak, pork and veggies. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Sea Salt, Paprika, Sugar...

View full details
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Funken Hot Yellow Moruga Edition - Heat

Funken Hot Yellow Moruga Edition

Karma Sauce
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
In stock

A limited edition version of Funken Hot, made with Yellow Moruga Scorpion chiles. It starts with a rich sweetness upfront and finishes with a tangy...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Smoked Maple Ghost Pepper Mustard - Heat
Sold out

Smoked Maple Ghost Pepper Mustard

Parker's Gourmet
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Out of stock

A fiery and flavorful mustard made with Smoked Vermont Maple Syrup, that tastes delicious on burgers and hot dogs or as a dip for pretzels.  Heat L...

View full details
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Sold out
Seed Ranch Smoked Jalapeño - Heat

Seed Ranch Smoked Jalapeño

Seed Ranch Flavor Co.
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Low stock

A unique medium heat sauce featuring Chipotle peppers, dates, and carrots. The smoky flavor of Chipotles are well complemented with the subtle swee...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Hellfire First Blood - Heat

Hellfire First Blood

Hellfire Hot Sauce
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

An intensely fiery blend of Ghost, Scorpion, Red 7 Pot, and Chocolate Habanero peppers, along with sun-dried tomatoes, garlic, and lemon. Heat Leve...

View full details
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Wildberry Whoop-ass - Heat
Sold out

Wildberry Whoop-ass

PexPeppers
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Out of stock

A scorching combination of strawberry and blackberry purees and Red Primo 7 Pot chile peppers, rounded out with fresh honey.  Heat Level: Extra Hot...

View full details
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Sold out
Montana Rooster Sauce - Heat
Sold out

Montana Rooster Sauce

Arthur Wayne Hot Sauce
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Out of stock

A mellow sriracha style sauce with a bright garlicky tang to it, and a bit of sweetness from pineapple. Perfect for rice dishes, stir-fry, and even...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Sold out
Fatalii Pepper Grinder - Heat

Fatalii Pepper Grinder

Heat Hot Sauce Shop
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
In stock

A glass grinder jar full of Fatalii pepper flakes, a distinctive citrusy pepper originating in Central Africa. Hotter than a Habanero, with a slow ...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
The Machine Hot Wing Sauce - Heat

The Machine Hot Wing Sauce

Volcanic Peppers
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
In stock

The Machine is an extra hot wing sauce that's packed with flavor. It's named for Steve "The Machine" Smallwood, a legendary hot pepper eater known ...

View full details
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Colfax Killer - Heat

Colfax Killer

Sauce Leopard
$9.50 - $9.50
$9.50
$9.50 - $9.50
$9.50
In stock

A perfectly balanced tropical hot sauce featuring mangoes, pineapples, and bananas, along with the delayed heat of fresh Habanero peppers. Heat Lev...

View full details
$9.50 - $9.50
$9.50
$9.50 - $9.50
$9.50
Haba Haba "Spicy Tomatillo" - Heat
Sold out

Haba Haba "Spicy Tomatillo"

Arthur Wayne Hot Sauce
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Out of stock

Bright and citrusy with all the classic flavors of a verde sauce, Arthur Wayne's Spicy Tomatillo is perfect for any sort of Mexican food and eggs. ...

View full details
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
$9.99 - $9.99
$9.99
Sold out
18 Conejo - Heat

18 Conejo

Chile Lengua de Fuego
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
In stock

A thick Caribbean style sauce featuring Scotch Bonnet peppers backed up with the classic combo of fresh carrots, vidalia onion, and lime juice. The...

View full details
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$11.99
$11.99 - $11.99
$11.99
Death By Douglah - Heat

Death By Douglah

Volcanic Peppers
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
In stock

A sweet and very spicy hot sauce made with pineapple, black cherries and a blend of 7-Pot Douglahs, Chocolate Bhut Jolokias and Scotch Bonnet peppe...

View full details
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
$10.99 - $10.99
$10.99
Seed Ranch Hot Thai Green - Heat

Seed Ranch Hot Thai Green

Seed Ranch Flavor Co.
$12.99 - $12.99
$12.99
$12.99 - $12.99
$12.99
In stock

A hotter version of Seed Ranch Flavor Co.'s Thai Green sauce, featuring lemongrass, Thai ginger, cilantro, and basil, with a nice balance of flavor...

View full details
$12.99 - $12.99
$12.99
$12.99 - $12.99
$12.99